The Volunteer of the Year Award is an award given annually to an Active League member whose commitment to the community and voluntarism is noteworthy.

The following women have been recipients of the award since its inception in 1994:
1994-1995 Sharon Crissy & Susan Keegan
1995-1996 Brenda Barrett & Courtney Rhorer
1996-1997 Melissa Stephan
1997-1998 Beth Finch
1998-1999 Susan Combs & Missy Scanlon
1999-2000 Kathleen Torok (deceased)
2000-2001 Susan Rayer
2001-2002 Maggie McElvein
2002-2003 Gabrielle Ingram
2003-2004 Amy Waterman
2004-2005 Julia Mitchell & Melanie Glasscock Simpson
2005-2006 Marian Blanchard
2006-2007 Brandy Hamby
2007-2008 Sarah Tedford
2008-2009 Amy Dineen
2010 Angie Straley-Fields
2011 Elizabeth McGee
2012 Brandy Pennington
2013 Mindy Sexton
2014 Sara Jean Waggoner
2015 Mary Leppo
2016 Nanci House
2017 Diane Verhalen
2018 Jessica Stigall
2019 Liz Sheehan
2020 Bridget Szczapinski
2021 Kelli Parmley